Creative Critical Review Rider

Generativity

What is being manifest by this writing?

Discipline

Is there a balance of showing and telling? How does this balance work?

Purpose

Does the text need the form; does the form need the text?

Lineage 

Is there a legible lineage of related writing in topic, form, reference or otherwise?

Translation

How are non-verbal, musical, somatic or other experiences translated into text?

Ethics

What is the ethical, somatic, and positional presence of the writing?

Voice 

How do authorial voice and author intentionality sit within the work?

Resolution

While there is no perfect, is the work resolved, convincing, finished enough?

Curiosity

To what extent does the work raise questions and/or propose answers?